部分属实

评分： 7.0/10

报告问题
Coalition
C0301

声明内容

“从原住民发展基金中拨款给一家渔业公司，以帮助其对抗原住民土地索赔。”
原住民
原始来源： Matthew Davis

原始来源

✅ 事实核查

核心hé xīn hé xīn 指控zhǐ kòng zhǐ kòng 在zài zài ** * ** * 事实上shì shí shàng shì shí shàng 是shì shì 准确zhǔn què zhǔn què 的de de ** * ** * 。。 。
The core claim is **factually accurate**.
 20182018 2018 年nián nián 1010 10 月yuè yuè ，， ， 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 事务部长shì wù bù zhǎng shì wù bù zhǎng NigelNigel Nigel ScullionScullion Scullion 批准pī zhǔn pī zhǔn 从cóng cóng IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy (( ( IASIAS IAS )) ) 向xiàng xiàng NTNT NT SeafoodSeafood Seafood CouncilCouncil Council (( ( NTSCNTSC NTSC )) ) 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 1515 15 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
In October 2018, Indigenous Affairs Minister Nigel Scullion approved a $150,000 grant from the Indigenous Advancement Strategy (IAS) to the NT Seafood Council (NTSC) [1].
 他tā tā 还hái hái 批准pī zhǔn pī zhǔn 向xiàng xiàng NTNT NT AmateurAmateur Amateur FishermenFishermen Fishermen '' ' ss s AssociationAssociation Association 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 1717 17 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán ，， ， 向xiàng xiàng NTNT NT CattlemenCattlemen Cattlemen '' ' ss s AssociationAssociation Association 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 16.516.5 16.5 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán —— — —— — 总计zǒng jì zǒng jì 约yuē yuē 48.548.5 48.5 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán [[ [ 22 2 ]] ] 。。 。
He also approved $170,000 to the NT Amateur Fishermen's Association and $165,000 to the NT Cattlemen's Association – a total of approximately $485,000 [2].
 ScullionScullion Scullion 部长bù zhǎng bù zhǎng 在zài zài 20182018 2018 年nián nián 1010 10 月yuè yuè 下旬xià xún xià xún 的de de 参议院cān yì yuàn cān yì yuàn 预算yù suàn yù suàn 听证会tīng zhèng huì tīng zhèng huì 上shàng shàng 确认què rèn què rèn 了le le 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] [[ [ 22 2 ]] ] 。。 。
Minister Scullion confirmed these grants during Senate estimates hearings in late October 2018 [1][2].
 ScullionScullion Scullion 曾于céng yú céng yú 19941994 1994 年nián nián 至zhì zhì 20012001 2001 年nián nián 担任dān rèn dān rèn NTSCNTSC NTSC 主席zhǔ xí zhǔ xí ，， ， 并bìng bìng 在zài zài 担任dān rèn dān rèn 主席zhǔ xí zhǔ xí 期间qī jiān qī jiān 代表dài biǎo dài biǎo 该gāi gāi 组织zǔ zhī zǔ zhī 在zài zài 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 纠纷jiū fēn jiū fēn 中zhōng zhōng 提供tí gōng tí gōng 证据zhèng jù zhèng jù [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Scullion had previously chaired the NTSC from 1994 to 2001, and gave evidence on behalf of that organization in Aboriginal land claim disputes during his tenure as chair [1].
 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 明确míng què míng què 旨在zhǐ zài zhǐ zài 资助zī zhù zī zhù "" " 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 费用fèi yòng fèi yòng ，， ， 实际上shí jì shàng shí jì shàng 是shì shì …… … …… … 向xiàng xiàng 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 专员zhuān yuán zhuān yuán 提出tí chū tí chū 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 主张zhǔ zhāng zhǔ zhāng "" " ，， ， 涉及shè jí shè jí 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi [[ [ 33 3 ]] ] 。。 。
The grants were specifically intended to fund "legal fees, effectively … to put forward a case of detriment to the land commissioner" regarding Aboriginal land claims [3].
 根据gēn jù gēn jù NTNT NT LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act ，， ， 认为rèn wéi rèn wéi 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 将jiāng jiāng 对duì duì 其qí qí 业务yè wù yè wù 或huò huò 个人利益gè rén lì yì gè rén lì yì 产生chǎn shēng chǎn shēng 负面影响fù miàn yǐng xiǎng fù miàn yǐng xiǎng 的de de 人rén rén 可以kě yǐ kě yǐ 提交tí jiāo tí jiāo "" " 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài "" " 申请shēn qǐng shēn qǐng 给gěi gěi AboriginalAboriginal Aboriginal LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner ，， ， 论证lùn zhèng lùn zhèng 其qí qí 未来wèi lái wèi lái 的de de 收入shōu rù shōu rù 、、 、 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 或huò huò 水资源shuǐ zī yuán shuǐ zī yuán 获取huò qǔ huò qǔ 将jiāng jiāng 如何rú hé rú hé 受到shòu dào shòu dào 影响yǐng xiǎng yǐng xiǎng [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Under the NT Land Rights Act, those who believe a land claim would negatively impact their business or personal interests can lodge "detriment" applications to the Aboriginal Land Commissioner arguing how their future access to income, land, or water would be affected [1].
 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 资金zī jīn zī jīn 明确míng què míng què 用于yòng yú yòng yú 帮助bāng zhù bāng zhù 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 为wèi wèi 长期cháng qī cháng qī 悬而未决xuán ér wèi jué xuán ér wèi jué 的de de 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi （（ （ 有些yǒu xiē yǒu xiē 已yǐ yǐ 搁置gē zhì gē zhì 近jìn jìn 3030 30 年nián nián ）） ） 准备zhǔn bèi zhǔn bèi 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 论证lùn zhèng lùn zhèng [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
The funds were explicitly used to help these industry groups prepare their legal arguments on detriment for outstanding land claims that had been held up – some for nearly 30 years [1].

缺失背景

然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 该gāi gāi 指控zhǐ kòng zhǐ kòng 忽略hū lüè hū lüè 了le le 几个jǐ gè jǐ gè 从根本上cóng gēn běn shàng cóng gēn běn shàng 改变gǎi biàn gǎi biàn 情况qíng kuàng qíng kuàng 的de de 重要zhòng yào zhòng yào 的de de 背景bèi jǐng bèi jǐng 要素yào sù yào sù ：： ：
However, the claim omits several important contextual elements that fundamentally alter the picture: **1.
 ** * ** * 11 1 .. . 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 所说suǒ shuō suǒ shuō 的de de 资金zī jīn zī jīn 用途yòng tú yòng tú ：： ： ** * ** * 虽然suī rán suī rán 批评者pī píng zhě pī píng zhě 将jiāng jiāng 此cǐ cǐ 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 为wèi wèi 资助zī zhù zī zhù "" " 对抗duì kàng duì kàng "" " 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 资金zī jīn zī jīn ，， ， 但dàn dàn 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 坚称jiān chēng jiān chēng 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 资金zī jīn zī jīn 用于yòng yú yòng yú IASIAS IAS 指导方针zhǐ dǎo fāng zhēn zhǐ dǎo fāng zhēn 下xià xià 的de de 合法hé fǎ hé fǎ 目的mù dì mù dì 。。 。
The funding purpose according to government:** While critics framed this as funding to "fight" land claims, the government maintained the funds were for legitimate purposes under IAS guidelines.
 DepartmentDepartment Department ofof of PrimePrime Prime MinisterMinister Minister andand and CabinetCabinet Cabinet 表示biǎo shì biǎo shì ，， ， 该gāi gāi 资金zī jīn zī jīn 有yǒu yǒu "" " 两个liǎng gè liǎng gè 组成部分zǔ chéng bù fèn zǔ chéng bù fèn "" " ：： ： (( ( 11 1 )) ) 教育jiào yù jiào yù 行业háng yè háng yè 成员chéng yuán chéng yuán 了解liǎo jiě liǎo jiě NTNT NT LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act 和hé hé 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 权利quán lì quán lì 问题wèn tí wèn tí ，， ， (( ( 22 2 )) ) 允许yǔn xǔ yǔn xǔ 组织zǔ zhī zǔ zhī 在zài zài 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 程序chéng xù chéng xù 中zhōng zhōng 代表dài biǎo dài biǎo 其qí qí 成员chéng yuán chéng yuán 的de de 利益lì yì lì yì [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
The Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet stated the funding had "two components": (1) to educate industry members on the Land Rights Act and Aboriginal land rights issues in the NT, and (2) to allow organizations to represent their members' interests in the land claims process [1].
 ScullionScullion Scullion 还hái hái 告诉gào sù gào sù GuardianGuardian Guardian AustraliaAustralia Australia ，， ， 该gāi gāi 资金zī jīn zī jīn 可kě kě 用于yòng yú yòng yú "" " 开发kāi fā kāi fā 有关yǒu guān yǒu guān NTNT NT 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 和hé hé 海洋hǎi yáng hǎi yáng 国土guó tǔ guó tǔ 、、 、 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 权利quán lì quán lì 历史lì shǐ lì shǐ 和hé hé 立法lì fǎ lì fǎ 的de de 教育资源jiào yù zī yuán jiào yù zī yuán 和hé hé 培训péi xùn péi xùn 材料cái liào cái liào "" " [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Scullion also told Guardian Australia the funding could be used "to develop education resources and training materials on Aboriginal land and sea country in the Northern Territory, Aboriginal land rights history and legislation" [1]. **2.
 ** * ** * 22 2 .. . 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià ：： ： ** * ** * 根据gēn jù gēn jù NTNT NT LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act 本身běn shēn běn shēn ，， ， 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 评估píng gū píng gū 是shì shì 强制性qiáng zhì xìng qiáng zhì xìng 程序chéng xù chéng xù 的de de 一部分yī bù fèn yī bù fèn 。。 。
The legal framework:** Under the NT Land Rights Act itself, detriment assessment is a mandatory part of the process.
 AboriginalAboriginal Aboriginal LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner 必须bì xū bì xū 依法yī fǎ yī fǎ 考虑kǎo lǜ kǎo lǜ 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi —— — —— — 它们tā men tā men 不是bú shì bú shì 可选项kě xuǎn xiàng kě xuǎn xiàng [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
The Aboriginal Land Commissioner must consider detriment claims by law – they are not optional [1].
 这zhè zhè 不是bú shì bú shì 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 程序chéng xù chéng xù 中zhōng zhōng 的de de 自由zì yóu zì yóu 裁量cái liàng cái liàng 或huò huò 不bù bù 寻常xún cháng xún cháng 要素yào sù yào sù ；； ； 它tā tā 是shì shì 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 权利quán lì quán lì 确定què dìng què dìng 方式fāng shì fāng shì 的de de 结构性jié gòu xìng jié gòu xìng 组成部分zǔ chéng bù fèn zǔ chéng bù fèn 。。 。
This is not a discretionary or unusual element of the land claims process; it is structural to how land rights determinations work. **3.
 ** * ** * 33 3 .. . 替代tì dài tì dài 资金zī jīn zī jīn 渠道qú dào qú dào ：： ： ** * ** * 该gāi gāi 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 决定jué dìng jué dìng 引发yǐn fā yǐn fā 了le le 一个yí gè yí gè 程序性chéng xù xìng chéng xù xìng 担忧dān yōu dān yōu —— — —— — NorthernNorthern Northern LandLand Land CouncilCouncil Council 主席zhǔ xí zhǔ xí JoeJoe Joe MorrisonMorrison Morrison 指出zhǐ chū zhǐ chū ，， ， 根据gēn jù gēn jù LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act ，， ， 如果rú guǒ rú guǒ 各方gè fāng gè fāng 需要xū yào xū yào 协助xié zhù xié zhù 提交tí jiāo tí jiāo 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi ，， ， "" " 这应zhè yīng zhè yīng 由yóu yóu AttorneyAttorney Attorney -- - GeneralGeneral General '' ' ss s departmentdepartment department 处理chǔ lǐ chǔ lǐ ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 由yóu yóu 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 事务部长shì wù bù zhǎng shì wù bù zhǎng 处理chǔ lǐ chǔ lǐ "" " [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Alternative funding avenue:** The grant decision raised a procedural concern – the Northern Land Council chairman Joe Morrison pointed out that under the Land Rights Act, if parties require assistance submitting detriment claims, "that's dealt with by the Attorney-General's department, not by the Indigenous Affairs Minister" [1].
 这zhè zhè 表明biǎo míng biǎo míng 问题wèn tí wèn tí 更gèng gèng 多duō duō 在于zài yú zài yú 资金zī jīn zī jīn 渠道qú dào qú dào 选择xuǎn zé xuǎn zé ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 是否shì fǒu shì fǒu 应yīng yīng 存在cún zài cún zài 。。 。
This suggests the issue was more about funding channel choice than whether detriment claims should exist at all. **4.
 ** * ** * 44 4 .. . 联盟党lián méng dǎng lián méng dǎng 的de de 论点lùn diǎn lùn diǎn ：： ： ** * ** * 联盟党lián méng dǎng lián méng dǎng 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 辩称biàn chēng biàn chēng 其qí qí 已yǐ yǐ 向xiàng xiàng IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy 总体zǒng tǐ zǒng tǐ 提供tí gōng tí gōng 4949 49 亿澳元yì ào yuán yì ào yuán ，， ， 包括bāo kuò bāo kuò 专门zhuān mén zhuān mén 向xiàng xiàng NorthernNorthern Northern LandLand Land CouncilCouncil Council 提供tí gōng tí gōng 750750 750 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán 以yǐ yǐ 推进tuī jìn tuī jìn 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi ，， ， 并bìng bìng 额外é wài é wài 向xiàng xiàng LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner 提供tí gōng tí gōng 100100 100 万澳元wàn ào yuán wàn ào yuán [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Coalition's argument:** The Coalition government argued it had provided $4.9 billion to the Indigenous Advancement Strategy overall, including $7.5 million to the Northern Land Council specifically to progress claims, and an additional $1 million to the Land Commissioner [1].
 一位yī wèi yī wèi 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 发言人fā yán rén fā yán rén 表示biǎo shì biǎo shì ：： ： "" " 如果rú guǒ rú guǒ 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 乐于lè yú lè yú 看到kàn dào kàn dào 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 未决wèi jué wèi jué 的de de 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 被bèi bèi 无限期wú xiàn qī wú xiàn qī 搁置gē zhì gē zhì ，， ， 并bìng bìng 剥夺bō duó bō duó 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 社区shè qū shè qū 立即lì jí lì jí 解决jiě jué jiě jué 未决wèi jué wèi jué 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 利益lì yì lì yì ，， ， 他们tā men tā men 应该yīng gāi yīng gāi 直接zhí jiē zhí jiē 说shuō shuō 出来chū lái chū lái "" " [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
A government spokesman stated: "If Labor is happy to see these outstanding land claims kicked off to the never never and deprive Aboriginal communities of the benefits of settling outstanding claims now, they should just come out and say so" [1]. **5.
 ** * ** * 55 5 .. . 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 解决jiě jué jiě jué 背景bèi jǐng bèi jǐng ：： ： ** * ** * ScullionScullion Scullion 于yú yú 20182018 2018 年nián nián 77 7 月yuè yuè 要求yāo qiú yāo qiú LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner 研究yán jiū yán jiū 如何rú hé rú hé 解决jiě jué jiě jué 未决wèi jué wèi jué 的de de 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 问题wèn tí wèn tí ，， ， 因为yīn wèi yīn wèi 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 技术性jì shù xìng jì shù xìng 障碍zhàng ài zhàng ài 正zhèng zhèng 阻止zǔ zhǐ zǔ zhǐ 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 最终zuì zhōng zuì zhōng 确定què dìng què dìng [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Claim resolution context:** Scullion had asked the Land Commissioner in July 2018 to examine how to resolve outstanding detriment issues, as these technical barriers were preventing claims from being finalized [1].
 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 于yú yú 20182018 2018 年nián nián 55 5 月yuè yuè 获批huò pī huò pī ，， ， 正是zhèng shì zhèng shì 在zài zài 试图shì tú shì tú 推动tuī dòng tuī dòng 停滞tíng zhì tíng zhì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 向前xiàng qián xiàng qián 进展jìn zhǎn jìn zhǎn 的de de 背景bèi jǐng bèi jǐng 下xià xià 。。 。
The grants were approved in May 2018 in this context of trying to move stalled claims forward.

来源可信度评估

原始yuán shǐ yuán shǐ 来源lái yuán lái yuán 是shì shì 可信kě xìn kě xìn 的de de 主流zhǔ liú zhǔ liú 新闻媒体xīn wén méi tǐ xīn wén méi tǐ ：： ：
The original sources are credible, mainstream journalism outlets: - **The Guardian** [1] is an internationally recognized broadsheet newspaper with strong editorial standards, published by Guardian News & Media Limited.
 -- - ** * ** * TheThe The GuardianGuardian Guardian ** * ** * [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 是shì shì 由yóu yóu GuardianGuardian Guardian NewsNews News CLAIMCLAIM CLAIM __ _ JSONJSON JSON __ _ PLACEHOLDERPLACEHOLDER PLACEHOLDER MediaMedia Media LimitedLimited Limited 出版chū bǎn chū bǎn 的de de 国际guó jì guó jì 公认gōng rèn gōng rèn 的de de 大报dà bào dà bào ，， ， 具有jù yǒu jù yǒu 强大qiáng dà qiáng dà 的de de 编辑biān jí biān jí 标准biāo zhǔn biāo zhǔn 。。 。
The article was reported by Lorena Allam, an established journalist, and was framed as "exclusive" reporting [1]. - **SBS/NITV** [2] is Australia's national public broadcaster's Indigenous news service, also a credible mainstream source.
 该gāi gāi 文章wén zhāng wén zhāng 由yóu yóu 资深zī shēn zī shēn 记者jì zhě jì zhě LorenaLorena Lorena AllamAllam Allam 报道bào dào bào dào ，， ， 并bìng bìng 被bèi bèi 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 为wèi wèi "" " 独家dú jiā dú jiā "" " 报道bào dào bào dào [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Both sources provide factual reporting on what occurred.
 -- - ** * ** * SBSSBS SBS // / NITVNITV NITV ** * ** * [[ [ 22 2 ]] ] 是shì shì 澳大利亚ào dà lì yà ào dà lì yà 国家guó jiā guó jiā 公共广播gōng gòng guǎng bō gōng gòng guǎng bō 公司gōng sī gōng sī 的de de 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 新闻xīn wén xīn wén 服务fú wù fú wù ，， ， 同样tóng yàng tóng yàng 是shì shì 可信kě xìn kě xìn 的de de 主流zhǔ liú zhǔ liú 来源lái yuán lái yuán 。。 。
However, both sources emphasize the critical framing – that Indigenous funds were diverted to fight land claims – without providing proportional emphasis to the government's explanations about the funding purpose or the structural role of detriment claims in the Land Rights Act framework.
 两个liǎng gè liǎng gè 来源lái yuán lái yuán 都dōu dōu 提供tí gōng tí gōng 了le le 关于guān yú guān yú 所suǒ suǒ 发生fā shēng fā shēng 事件shì jiàn shì jiàn 的de de 事实shì shí shì shí 报道bào dào bào dào 。。 。
Michael West Media, another original source mentioned in searches, explicitly categorizes this as a "rort" (misuse of funds), which reflects partisan framing rather than purely neutral analysis [4].
 然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 两个liǎng gè liǎng gè 来源lái yuán lái yuán 都dōu dōu 强调qiáng diào qiáng diào 批评性pī píng xìng pī píng xìng 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià —— — —— — 即jí jí 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 资金zī jīn zī jīn 被bèi bèi 转移zhuǎn yí zhuǎn yí 用于yòng yú yòng yú 对抗duì kàng duì kàng 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi —— — —— — 而ér ér 没有méi yǒu méi yǒu 对duì duì 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 关于guān yú guān yú 资金zī jīn zī jīn 用途yòng tú yòng tú 的de de 解释jiě shì jiě shì 或huò huò 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 在zài zài LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 中zhōng zhōng 的de de 结构性jié gòu xìng jié gòu xìng 作用zuò yòng zuò yòng 给予jǐ yǔ jǐ yǔ 相称xiāng chèn xiāng chèn 的de de 重视zhòng shì zhòng shì 。。 。
MichaelMichael Michael WestWest West MediaMedia Media 是shì shì 搜索sōu suǒ sōu suǒ 中zhōng zhōng 提到tí dào tí dào 的de de 另lìng lìng 一个yí gè yí gè 原始yuán shǐ yuán shǐ 来源lái yuán lái yuán ，， ， 明确míng què míng què 将jiāng jiāng 此cǐ cǐ 归类guī lèi guī lèi 为wèi wèi "" " rortrort rort "" " （（ （ 资金zī jīn zī jīn 滥用làn yòng làn yòng ）） ） ，， ， 这zhè zhè 反映fǎn yìng fǎn yìng 了le le 党派dǎng pài dǎng pài 性xìng xìng 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 纯粹chún cuì chún cuì 中立zhōng lì zhōng lì 的de de 分析fēn xī fēn xī [[ [ 44 4 ]] ] 。。 。
⚖️

工党对比

** * ** * 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 是否shì fǒu shì fǒu 做过zuò guò zuò guò 类似lèi sì lèi sì 的de de 事情shì qíng shì qíng ？？ ？
**Did Labor do something similar?** Searches conducted: "Labor government Indigenous funding controversial", "Labor Indigenous affairs funding criticism", "Labor Aboriginal land claims policy".
 ** * ** *
The searches did not yield specific equivalent instances of Labor funding industry groups to lodge detriment claims.
 进行jìn xíng jìn xíng 的de de 搜索sōu suǒ sōu suǒ ：： ： "" " LaborLabor Labor governmentgovernment government IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous fundingfunding funding controversialcontroversial controversial "" " 、、 、 "" " LaborLabor Labor IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous affairsaffairs affairs fundingfunding funding criticismcriticism criticism "" " 、、 、 "" " LaborLabor Labor AboriginalAboriginal Aboriginal landland land claimsclaims claims policypolicy policy "" " 。。 。
However, this is not surprising because: 1. **The funding mechanism was novel:** Using IAS funding for detriment claims was a Coalition policy innovation in 2018.
 搜索sōu suǒ sōu suǒ 未找到wèi zhǎo dào wèi zhǎo dào 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 资助zī zhù zī zhù 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 提交tí jiāo tí jiāo 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 具体jù tǐ jù tǐ 等同děng tóng děng tóng 实例shí lì shí lì 。。 。
This approach to funding detriment claims doesn't appear to have a direct Labor equivalent in available sources. 2. **Labor's record on land claims:** Under Labor governments, Aboriginal land claims processes also required detriment assessment.
 然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 这zhè zhè 并bìng bìng 不bù bù 令人lìng rén lìng rén 惊讶jīng yà jīng yà ，， ， 因为yīn wèi yīn wèi ：： ：
When the Rudd/Gillard Labor governments operated the Indigenous portfolio, they also processed land claims through frameworks requiring detriment consideration, though searches did not reveal they funded industry groups in the same way. 3. **The broader context:** Both major parties have supported resolving Northern Territory land claims through established legal frameworks, though their approaches and funding mechanisms have differed.
 11 1 .. . ** * ** * 该gāi gāi 资金zī jīn zī jīn 机制jī zhì jī zhì 是shì shì 新颖xīn yǐng xīn yǐng 的de de ：： ： ** * ** * 使用shǐ yòng shǐ yòng IASIAS IAS 资金zī jīn zī jīn 用于yòng yú yòng yú 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 是shì shì 联盟党lián méng dǎng lián méng dǎng 20182018 2018 年nián nián 的de de 政策zhèng cè zhèng cè 创新chuàng xīn chuàng xīn 。。 。
The comparative analysis suggests this particular funding approach – using Indigenous Advancement Strategy monies to fund industry groups' detriment arguments – was specific to the Scullion model rather than a standard practice across both parties.
 这种zhè zhǒng zhè zhǒng 资助zī zhù zī zhù 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 方法fāng fǎ fāng fǎ 在zài zài 可用kě yòng kě yòng 来源lái yuán lái yuán 中zhōng zhōng 似乎sì hū sì hū 没有méi yǒu méi yǒu 直接zhí jiē zhí jiē 的de de 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 等同děng tóng děng tóng 做法zuò fǎ zuò fǎ 。。 。
22 2 .. . ** * ** * 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 在zài zài 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 方面fāng miàn fāng miàn 的de de 记录jì lù jì lù ：： ： ** * ** * 在zài zài 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 执政zhí zhèng zhí zhèng 期间qī jiān qī jiān ，， ， 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 程序chéng xù chéng xù 也yě yě 需要xū yào xū yào 进行jìn xíng jìn xíng 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 评估píng gū píng gū 。。 。
当dāng dāng RuddRudd Rudd // / GillardGillard Gillard 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 管理guǎn lǐ guǎn lǐ 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 事务shì wù shì wù 组合zǔ hé zǔ hé 时shí shí ，， ， 他们tā men tā men 也yě yě 通过tōng guò tōng guò 需要xū yào xū yào 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 考虑kǎo lǜ kǎo lǜ 的de de 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 处理chǔ lǐ chǔ lǐ 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi ，， ， 尽管jǐn guǎn jǐn guǎn 搜索sōu suǒ sōu suǒ 显示xiǎn shì xiǎn shì 他们tā men tā men 未曾wèi céng wèi céng 以yǐ yǐ 相同xiāng tóng xiāng tóng 方式fāng shì fāng shì 资助zī zhù zī zhù 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 。。 。
33 3 .. . ** * ** * 更gèng gèng 广泛guǎng fàn guǎng fàn 的de de 背景bèi jǐng bèi jǐng ：： ： ** * ** * 两个liǎng gè liǎng gè 主要zhǔ yào zhǔ yào 政党zhèng dǎng zhèng dǎng 都dōu dōu 支持zhī chí zhī chí 通过tōng guò tōng guò 既定jì dìng jì dìng 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 解决jiě jué jiě jué NTNT NT 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi ，， ， 尽管jǐn guǎn jǐn guǎn 他们tā men tā men 的de de 方法fāng fǎ fāng fǎ 和hé hé 资金zī jīn zī jīn 机制jī zhì jī zhì 有所不同yǒu suǒ bù tóng yǒu suǒ bù tóng 。。 。
比较bǐ jiào bǐ jiào 分析表明fēn xī biǎo míng fēn xī biǎo míng ，， ， 这种zhè zhǒng zhè zhǒng 特定tè dìng tè dìng 的de de 资金zī jīn zī jīn 做法zuò fǎ zuò fǎ —— — —— — 使用shǐ yòng shǐ yòng IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy 资金zī jīn zī jīn 资助zī zhù zī zhù 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 的de de 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 论证lùn zhèng lùn zhèng —— — —— — 是shì shì ScullionScullion Scullion 模式mó shì mó shì 特有tè yǒu tè yǒu 的de de ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 两党liǎng dǎng liǎng dǎng 都dōu dōu 采用cǎi yòng cǎi yòng 的de de 标准biāo zhǔn biāo zhǔn 做法zuò fǎ zuò fǎ 。。 。
🌐

平衡视角

** * ** * 合法hé fǎ hé fǎ 的de de 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 论点lùn diǎn lùn diǎn ：： ： ** * ** * ScullionScullion Scullion 部长bù zhǎng bù zhǎng 和hé hé 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 坚称jiān chēng jiān chēng 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 促进cù jìn cù jìn 了le le 合法hé fǎ hé fǎ 程序chéng xù chéng xù 。。 。
**The legitimate government argument:** Minister Scullion and the government maintained that the grants facilitated legitimate processes.
 根据gēn jù gēn jù NTNT NT LandLand Land RightsRights Rights ActAct Act ，， ， 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 是shì shì AboriginalAboriginal Aboriginal LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner 必须bì xū bì xū 考虑kǎo lǜ kǎo lǜ 的de de 强制性qiáng zhì xìng qiáng zhì xìng 要素yào sù yào sù —— — —— — 不是bú shì bú shì 旨在zhǐ zài zhǐ zài 阻碍zǔ ài zǔ ài 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 可选kě xuǎn kě xuǎn 附加fù jiā fù jiā 项xiàng xiàng [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Under the NT Land Rights Act, detriment claims are mandatory considerations for the Aboriginal Land Commissioner – not optional extras designed to obstruct land claims [1].
 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 的de de 立场lì chǎng lì chǎng 是shì shì ，， ， 如果rú guǒ rú guǒ 没有méi yǒu méi yǒu 对duì duì 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 的de de 协助xié zhù xié zhù 来lái lái 正式zhèng shì zhèng shì 阐明chǎn míng chǎn míng 其qí qí 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 立场lì chǎng lì chǎng ，， ， 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 就jiù jiù 无法wú fǎ wú fǎ 通过tōng guò tōng guò 适当shì dàng shì dàng 的de de 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 程序chéng xù chéng xù 推进tuī jìn tuī jìn 。。 。
The government's position was that without assistance for industry groups to formally articulate their detriment position, claims could not proceed through proper legal process.
 根据gēn jù gēn jù 该gāi gāi 立法lì fǎ lì fǎ ，， ， 这zhè zhè 在zài zài 事实上shì shí shàng shì shí shàng 是shì shì 正确zhèng què zhèng què 的de de [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
This is factually correct under the legislation [1].
 此外cǐ wài cǐ wài ，， ， 几项jǐ xiàng jǐ xiàng 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 已因yǐ yīn yǐ yīn 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 问题wèn tí wèn tí 未wèi wèi 解决jiě jué jiě jué 而ér ér pendingpending pending 近jìn jìn 3030 30 年nián nián [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
Additionally, several land claims had been pending for nearly 30 years specifically because detriment issues were unresolved [1].
 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 声称shēng chēng shēng chēng 的de de 目标mù biāo mù biāo 是shì shì 通过tōng guò tōng guò 使shǐ shǐ 所有suǒ yǒu suǒ yǒu 各方gè fāng gè fāng —— — —— — 包括bāo kuò bāo kuò 行业háng yè háng yè 利益lì yì lì yì —— — —— — 能够néng gòu néng gòu 提出tí chū tí chū 其qí qí 正式zhèng shì zhèng shì 立场lì chǎng lì chǎng ，， ， unblockunblock unblock 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi ，， ， 从而cóng ér cóng ér 使shǐ shǐ LandLand Land CommissionerCommissioner Commissioner 能够néng gòu néng gòu 做出zuò chū zuò chū 决定jué dìng jué dìng ，， ， 社区shè qū shè qū 最终zuì zhōng zuì zhōng 能够néng gòu néng gòu 获得huò dé huò dé 和解hé jiě hé jiě 结果jié guǒ jié guǒ 。。 。
The government's stated goal was to unblock these claims by enabling all parties – including industry interests – to present their formal positions, allowing the Land Commissioner to make determinations and communities to finally receive settlement outcomes. **The legitimate criticism:** However, critics raised valid concerns: 1. **Conflict of interest:** Scullion had directly chaired the NTSC from 1994-2001 and given evidence on behalf of fishing interests in land claim disputes [1].
 ** * ** * 合法hé fǎ hé fǎ 的de de 批评pī píng pī píng ：： ： ** * ** * 然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 批评者pī píng zhě pī píng zhě 提出tí chū tí chū 了le le 合理hé lǐ hé lǐ 的de de 担忧dān yōu dān yōu ：： ：
Using his ministerial position to fund his former organization, even years later, created an appearance of impropriety and a direct conflict of interest [2][3]. 2. **Wrong funding channel:** As the Northern Land Council noted, parties seeking detriment funding should access the Attorney-General's Department's designated process, not the Indigenous Affairs Minister's Indigenous Advancement Strategy [1].
 11 1 .. . ** * ** * 利益冲突lì yì chōng tū lì yì chōng tū ：： ： ** * ** * ScullionScullion Scullion 曾于céng yú céng yú 19941994 1994 -- - 20012001 2001 年nián nián 直接zhí jiē zhí jiē 担任dān rèn dān rèn NTSCNTSC NTSC 主席zhǔ xí zhǔ xí ，， ， 并bìng bìng 代表dài biǎo dài biǎo 渔业yú yè yú yè 利益lì yì lì yì 在zài zài 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 纠纷jiū fēn jiū fēn 中zhōng zhōng 提供tí gōng tí gōng 证据zhèng jù zhèng jù [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
This was a procedural/governance issue – the funds were redirected away from their stated purpose. 3. **Purpose misalignment:** The Indigenous Advancement Strategy was created "to improve the way the government does business with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, to ensure funding actually achieves outcomes" – specifically to advance Indigenous interests [1].
 多年duō nián duō nián 后hòu hòu 利用lì yòng lì yòng 其qí qí 部长bù zhǎng bù zhǎng 职位zhí wèi zhí wèi 资助zī zhù zī zhù 其前qí qián qí qián 组织zǔ zhī zǔ zhī ，， ， 造成zào chéng zào chéng 了le le 不当bù dàng bù dàng 行为xíng wéi xíng wéi 的de de 表象biǎo xiàng biǎo xiàng 和hé hé 直接zhí jiē zhí jiē 的de de 利益冲突lì yì chōng tū lì yì chōng tū [[ [ 22 2 ]] ] [[ [ 33 3 ]] ] 。。 。
Using it to fund industry groups' legal arguments against Indigenous land claims represented a fundamental misalignment with the fund's stated purpose [1][3]. 4. **Lack of transparency:** Labor Senator Malarndirri McCarthy raised concerns about the absence of transparency in the decision-making process, stating "there are far more questions than there are answers" [1].
 22 2 .. . ** * ** * 错误cuò wù cuò wù 的de de 资金zī jīn zī jīn 渠道qú dào qú dào ：： ： ** * ** * 正如zhèng rú zhèng rú NorthernNorthern Northern LandLand Land CouncilCouncil Council 所suǒ suǒ 指出zhǐ chū zhǐ chū 的de de ，， ， 寻求xún qiú xún qiú 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 资金zī jīn zī jīn 的de de 各方gè fāng gè fāng 应yīng yīng 通过tōng guò tōng guò AttorneyAttorney Attorney -- - GeneralGeneral General '' ' ss s DepartmentDepartment Department 的de de 指定zhǐ dìng zhǐ dìng 程序chéng xù chéng xù 获取huò qǔ huò qǔ ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 通过tōng guò tōng guò 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 事务部长shì wù bù zhǎng shì wù bù zhǎng 的de de IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
There was no public consultation or tendering process announced.
 这是zhè shì zhè shì 一个yí gè yí gè 程序chéng xù chéng xù // / 治理zhì lǐ zhì lǐ 问题wèn tí wèn tí —— — —— — 资金zī jīn zī jīn 被bèi bèi 从cóng cóng 其qí qí 规定guī dìng guī dìng 用途yòng tú yòng tú 转移zhuǎn yí zhuǎn yí 。。 。
33 3 .. . ** * ** * 用途yòng tú yòng tú 不bù bù 一致yí zhì yí zhì ：： ： ** * ** * IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy 的de de 创建chuàng jiàn chuàng jiàn 是shì shì "" " 为了wèi le wèi le 改善gǎi shàn gǎi shàn 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 与yǔ yǔ 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 和hé hé 托雷斯tuō léi sī tuō léi sī 海峡hǎi xiá hǎi xiá 岛民dǎo mín dǎo mín 开展业务kāi zhǎn yè wù kāi zhǎn yè wù 的de de 方式fāng shì fāng shì ，， ， 确保què bǎo què bǎo 资金zī jīn zī jīn 实际shí jì shí jì 取得qǔ dé qǔ dé 成果chéng guǒ chéng guǒ "" " —— — —— — 特别tè bié tè bié 是shì shì 为了wèi le wèi le 推进tuī jìn tuī jìn 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 利益lì yì lì yì [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
将jiāng jiāng 其qí qí 用于yòng yú yòng yú 资助zī zhù zī zhù 行业háng yè háng yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 反对fǎn duì fǎn duì 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 的de de 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 论证lùn zhèng lùn zhèng ，， ， 代表dài biǎo dài biǎo 了le le 与yǔ yǔ 基金jī jīn jī jīn 规定guī dìng guī dìng 用途yòng tú yòng tú 的de de 根本性gēn běn xìng gēn běn xìng 不bù bù 一致yí zhì yí zhì [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] [[ [ 33 3 ]] ] 。。 。
44 4 .. . ** * ** * 缺乏quē fá quē fá 透明度tòu míng dù tòu míng dù ：： ： ** * ** * 工党gōng dǎng gōng dǎng 参议员cān yì yuán cān yì yuán MalarndirriMalarndirri Malarndirri McCarthyMcCarthy McCarthy 对duì duì 决策jué cè jué cè 过程guò chéng guò chéng 中zhōng zhōng 缺乏quē fá quē fá 透明度tòu míng dù tòu míng dù 表示biǎo shì biǎo shì 担忧dān yōu dān yōu ，， ， 称chēng chēng "" " 问题wèn tí wèn tí 远远yuǎn yuǎn yuǎn yuǎn 多于duō yú duō yú 答案dá àn dá àn "" " [[ [ 11 1 ]] ] 。。 。
没有méi yǒu méi yǒu 公布gōng bù gōng bù 公众gōng zhòng gōng zhòng 咨询zī xún zī xún 或huò huò 招标zhāo biāo zhāo biāo 程序chéng xù chéng xù 。。 。

部分属实

7.0

/ 10

该gāi gāi 指控zhǐ kòng zhǐ kòng 的de de 事实shì shí shì shí 要素yào sù yào sù 是shì shì 准确zhǔn què zhǔn què 的de de ：： ： ScullionScullion Scullion 确实què shí què shí 批准pī zhǔn pī zhǔn 了le le 从cóng cóng IndigenousIndigenous Indigenous AdvancementAdvancement Advancement StrategyStrategy Strategy 向xiàng xiàng 渔业yú yè yú yè 和hé hé 畜牧业xù mù yè xù mù yè 团体tuán tǐ tuán tǐ 的de de 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn ，， ， 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 被bèi bèi 用于yòng yú yòng yú 帮助bāng zhù bāng zhù 在zài zài 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 权利quán lì quán lì 纠纷jiū fēn jiū fēn 中zhōng zhōng 提交tí jiāo tí jiāo 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 。。 。
The factual elements of the claim are accurate: Scullion did approve grants from the Indigenous Advancement Strategy to fishing and cattle industry groups, and these grants were used to help lodge detriment claims in land rights disputes.
 然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 该gāi gāi 指控zhǐ kòng zhǐ kòng 将jiāng jiāng 资金zī jīn zī jīn 描述miáo shù miáo shù 为wèi wèi "" " 以yǐ yǐ 帮助bāng zhù bāng zhù 其qí qí 对抗duì kàng duì kàng 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi "" " 过度guò dù guò dù 简化jiǎn huà jiǎn huà 了le le 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 和hé hé 程序chéng xù chéng xù 背景bèi jǐng bèi jǐng 。。 。
However, the claim's framing as money given "to help it fight Indigenous land claims" oversimplifies the legal and procedural context.
 这些zhè xiē zhè xiē 拨款bō kuǎn bō kuǎn 资助zī zhù zī zhù 的de de 是shì shì 强制性qiáng zhì xìng qiáng zhì xìng 法定程序fǎ dìng chéng xù fǎ dìng chéng xù 的de de 参与cān yù cān yù ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 简单jiǎn dān jiǎn dān 地dì dì "" " 对抗duì kàng duì kàng "" " 索赔suǒ péi suǒ péi 。。 。
The grants funded participation in a mandatory statutory process, not simply "fighting" claims.
 然而rán ér rán ér ，， ， 更gèng gèng 严重yán zhòng yán zhòng 的de de 问题wèn tí wèn tí 是shì shì 治理zhì lǐ zhì lǐ 失败shī bài shī bài ：： ： 使用shǐ yòng shǐ yòng 来自lái zì lái zì 错误cuò wù cuò wù 部门bù mén bù mén 渠道qú dào qú dào 的de de 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 重点zhòng diǎn zhòng diǎn 资金zī jīn zī jīn ，， ， 由yóu yóu 一位yī wèi yī wèi 与yǔ yǔ 受益shòu yì shòu yì 组织zǔ zhī zǔ zhī 有yǒu yǒu 直接zhí jiē zhí jiē 先前xiān qián xiān qián 关系guān xì guān xì 的de de 部长bù zhǎng bù zhǎng ，， ， 来lái lái 资助zī zhù zī zhù 反对fǎn duì fǎn duì 原住民yuán zhù mín yuán zhù mín 土地tǔ dì tǔ dì 权利quán lì quán lì 的de de 行业háng yè háng yè 立场lì chǎng lì chǎng 。。 。
However, the more serious issue is the governance failure: using Indigenous-focused funding from the wrong ministry channel, with a minister who had direct prior ties to the beneficiary organization, to fund industry positions against Indigenous land rights.
 这zhè zhè 代表dài biǎo dài biǎo 了le le 糟糕zāo gāo zāo gāo 的de de 判断pàn duàn pàn duàn 和hé hé 对duì duì 错误cuò wù cuò wù 资金zī jīn zī jīn 项目xiàng mù xiàng mù 的de de 滥用làn yòng làn yòng ，， ， 即使jí shǐ jí shǐ 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 程序chéng xù chéng xù 本身běn shēn běn shēn 是shì shì 合法hé fǎ hé fǎ 且qiě qiě 法律fǎ lǜ fǎ lǜ 要求yāo qiú yāo qiú 的de de 。。 。
This represented poor judgment and misuse of the wrong funding program, even if the detriment process itself is legitimate and required by law.
 该gāi gāi 指控zhǐ kòng zhǐ kòng 在zài zài 其qí qí 核心hé xīn hé xīn 主张zhǔ zhāng zhǔ zhāng 上shàng shàng 是shì shì ** * ** * 真实zhēn shí zhēn shí 的de de ** * ** * ，， ， 但dàn dàn 在zài zài 框架kuāng jià kuāng jià 上shàng shàng ** * ** * 部分bù fèn bù fèn 误导wù dǎo wù dǎo ** * ** * ，， ， 因为yīn wèi yīn wèi 它tā tā 忽略hū lüè hū lüè 了le le 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 评估píng gū píng gū 的de de 法定fǎ dìng fǎ dìng 义务yì wù yì wù 和hé hé 政府zhèng fǔ zhèng fǔ 的de de 理由lǐ yóu lǐ yóu 。。 。
The claim is **true in its core assertion** but **partially misleading in framing** by omitting the statutory obligation for detriment assessment and the government's rationale.
 真正zhēn zhèng zhēn zhèng 的de de 问题wèn tí wèn tí 在于zài yú zài yú 使用shǐ yòng shǐ yòng 了le le 错误cuò wù cuò wù 的de de 资金来源zī jīn lái yuán zī jīn lái yuán 并bìng bìng 造成zào chéng zào chéng 了le le 利益冲突lì yì chōng tū lì yì chōng tū ，， ， 而ér ér 非fēi fēi 资助zī zhù zī zhù 损害sǔn hài sǔn hài 论证lùn zhèng lùn zhèng 的de de 概念gài niàn gài niàn 合法性hé fǎ xìng hé fǎ xìng 。。 。
The real problem was using the wrong funding source and creating a conflict of interest, not the conceptual legitimacy of funding detriment arguments.

📚 来源与引用 (5)

  1. 1
    Indigenous advancement funds given to lobby groups impacted by Aboriginal land claims

    Indigenous advancement funds given to lobby groups impacted by Aboriginal land claims

    Indigenous groups fear public money is being used to try to undermine Aboriginal land claims, amid revelations almost $500,000 in Indigenous funding was given to lobby groups.

    Abc Net
  2. 2
    Indigenous affairs funding diverted to lobby groups opposed to native title

    Indigenous affairs funding diverted to lobby groups opposed to native title

    Nigel Scullion used $150,000 of money for alleviating Indigenous disadvantage to fund a fishing industry lobby group so it could argue how it would be negatively affected by native title land claims.

    Michael West
  3. 3
    Nigel Scullion gave Indigenous funding to his former fishing lobby group to fight land claims

    Nigel Scullion gave Indigenous funding to his former fishing lobby group to fight land claims

    Exclusive: Minister approved grant of $150,000 from Indigenous advancement strategy to NT Seafood Council – a group he once chaired

    the Guardian
  4. 4
    Scullion directs Indigenous funds to cattle and fishing lobby groups

    Scullion directs Indigenous funds to cattle and fishing lobby groups

    Nigel Scullion defends giving nearly half a million dollars to business groups to argue how they might be negatively impacted by Indigenous land claims.

    NITV
  5. 5
    malarndirrimccarthy.com.au

    Malarndirri McCarthy Media Release - Nigel Scullion gave Indigenous funding to his former fishing lobby group

    Malarndirrimccarthy Com

评分方法

1-3: 不实

事实错误或恶意捏造。

4-6: 部分属实

有一定真实性，但缺乏背景或有所偏颇。

7-9: 基本属实

仅有微小的技术性或措辞问题。

10: 准确

完全经过验证且客观公正。

方法论: 评分通过交叉参照政府官方记录、独立事实核查机构和原始文件确定。

Previous: C0300 Next: C0302