The Claim
“Described wind farms as 'utterly offensive' and 'a blight on the landscape'.”
Original Sources Provided
✅ FACTUAL VERIFICATION
VERIFIED TRUE. On May 2, 2014, then-Treasurer Joe Hockey made these exact comments during a radio interview on 2GB's Macquarie Radio with Alan Jones [1]. Speaking about his drive from Sydney to Canberra, Hockey stated: "I drive to Canberra to go to Parliament... and I must say I find those wind turbines around Lake George to be utterly offensive. I think they're a blight on the landscape" [2].
The comments were specifically referring to the Capital and Woodlawn wind farms at Lake George, located near Bungendore in NSW [3]. These turbines are operated by Infigen Energy and generate 189 megawatts of wind power used to supply Sydney's desalination plant [1].
The quotes were widely reported across mainstream media including ABC News, Sydney Morning Herald, and SBS at the time [1][2][4]. The remarks came during a discussion about the Abbott government's planned budget cuts to clean energy programs.
Missing Context
The specific context was budget discussions and personal aesthetic preference, not government policy. Hockey made these comments in response to questions about whether the government would target clean energy programs for budget cuts [1]. He was signaling the government's intent to reduce climate-related agency spending and cut "massive duplication" in environmental programs [2].
Hockey was not proposing to shut down existing wind farms. He explicitly acknowledged he could not stop the Lake George turbines: "We can't knock those ones off because they're into locked-in schemes and there is a certain contractual obligation I'm told associated with those things" [1].
The Abbott government had a broader pattern of anti-wind rhetoric. Prime Minister Tony Abbott made similar comments in June 2015, telling Alan Jones that wind farms are "visually awful" and have a "potential health impact" [4]. The Abbott government appointed a "wind farm commissioner" in 2015 to investigate complaints about turbines, a move the wind industry criticized as part of a "relentless anti-renewables campaign" [5].
Public opinion on wind farms was generally positive. The Clean Energy Council noted at the time that "upwards of 75 per cent" of Australians supported renewable energy from wind, sun, and waves [2]. The Bungendore Chamber of Commerce even featured wind turbines in its logo [2].
Health claims were scientifically disputed. A National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) report in February 2015 found "no consistent evidence" that wind farms have adverse effects on human health [4]. The report identified over 4,000 studies but found only 13 met sufficient scientific standards, and those were of poor quality due to small sample sizes and potential bias [4].
Source Credibility Assessment
The original source, Independent Australia, is an online progressive publication known for left-leaning political commentary [6]. The website publishes opinion pieces and political analysis from a progressive perspective. While the article accurately reported Hockey's comments, the publication's political alignment should be noted when assessing the framing of energy policy debates.
The claim's accuracy is independently verified by multiple mainstream sources including ABC News (Australia's public broadcaster), Sydney Morning Herald, and other reputable outlets [1][2]. The quotes themselves are not disputed.
Labor Comparison
Did Labor have a different position on wind energy?
Search conducted: "Labor government wind farm policy Australia renewable energy"
Finding: The Labor Party generally supported wind energy development and renewable energy targets. In their dissenting report to a Senate inquiry on wind turbines, Labor senators stated: "Australia's wind energy industry remains small in comparison both with its potential size and with the total size of wind energy installed around the world. However, to date it has played a vital role in abating the greenhouse gas emissions of Australia's electricity generation sector" [7].
Comparison: While Labor supported wind energy broadly, both parties had internal tensions regarding specific wind farm locations. The SMH article notes divisions within the NSW Coalition government between Planning Minister Pru Goward (anti-wind) and Environment Minister Rob Stokes (pro-wind) [2]. Similarly, Labor governments faced community opposition to specific wind farm proposals while maintaining overall support for the industry.
The Abbott government's position was notably more hostile to wind energy than the previous or subsequent Labor governments, with Abbott himself calling wind farms "visually awful" and actively seeking to reduce their numbers through the Renewable Energy Target reduction from 41,000 to 33,000 gigawatt-hours [4].
Balanced Perspective
Personal aesthetic preference vs. energy policy. Hockey's comments reflected his personal reaction to the visual impact of wind turbines rather than a technical assessment of their energy value. This personal preference influenced but did not solely determine government policy.
Legitimate concerns about visual impact exist. While polls showed majority support for renewable energy, local communities often oppose specific wind farm developments due to visual amenity concerns. This tension between national climate goals and local community preferences affects both sides of politics.
Economic arguments were also presented. Liberal MP Angus Taylor, whose electorate includes the Lake George wind farms, argued against wind farms on economic grounds rather than aesthetic ones: "The economics don't work. Right now wind requires massive subsidies over and above other means of reducing carbon emissions" [1].
However, the government's approach was criticized as inconsistent. Shadow Minister for Climate Change Mark Butler called Abbott "short-sighted" and "out of touch," noting that "renewable energy is enormously popular in Australia" [4].
Comparative context: The Abbott government's hostility to wind energy was stronger than typical across Australian governments. The establishment of a dedicated "wind farm commissioner" was unusual and viewed by critics as singling out one renewable energy technology for special scrutiny.
TRUE
8.0
out of 10
The claim is factually accurate. Joe Hockey did describe wind farms as "utterly offensive" and "a blight on the landscape" in a May 2014 radio interview [1][2]. These were his exact words, widely reported by mainstream media at the time. However, the claim should be understood in context: these were personal aesthetic comments made during budget discussions, not a formal policy position, and Hockey acknowledged contractual obligations prevented shutting down existing turbines. The Abbott government did subsequently reduce the Renewable Energy Target and appointed a wind farm commissioner, indicating broader institutional skepticism toward wind energy than reflected in this single quote [4][5].
Final Score
8.0
OUT OF 10
TRUE
The claim is factually accurate. Joe Hockey did describe wind farms as "utterly offensive" and "a blight on the landscape" in a May 2014 radio interview [1][2]. These were his exact words, widely reported by mainstream media at the time. However, the claim should be understood in context: these were personal aesthetic comments made during budget discussions, not a formal policy position, and Hockey acknowledged contractual obligations prevented shutting down existing turbines. The Abbott government did subsequently reduce the Renewable Energy Target and appointed a wind farm commissioner, indicating broader institutional skepticism toward wind energy than reflected in this single quote [4][5].
📚 SOURCES & CITATIONS (7)
-
1
abc.net.au
Federal Treasurer Joe Hockey says he finds wind turbines "utterly offensive", but is powerless to close down the ones operating outside Canberra.
Abc Net -
2
smh.com.au
Treasurer Joe Hockey has attacked wind farms as “utterly offensive and “a blight on the landscape” in the latest sign that the Abbott government intends to cut back on renewable energy.
The Sydney Morning Herald -
3
stopthesethings.com
**** In our last post we covered the Alan Jone’s interview with Federal Treasurer Joe Hockey that’s sent the wind industry and its parasites into a tailspin. Apart from the fact that Joe detests th…
STOP THESE THINGS -
4
sbs.com.au
Wind farms are 'visually awful' and have a 'potential health impact,' Prime Minister Tony Abbott has told radio host Alan Jones, adding that his government intends to reduce the number of turbines.
SBS News -
5
wattsupwiththat.com
Guest essay by Eric Worrall The Australian Renewables industry has reacted with fury to a leaked suggestion that a new “wind commissioner” will be appointed, to handle complaints about …
Watts Up With That? -
6
independentaustralia.net
Joe Hockey thinks wind turbines are a "blight on the landscape"; David Horton suggests he may like them better if they were covered in oil and coal dust.
Independent Australia -
7
aph.gov.au
Australian Labor Party Senators' Dissenting Report 1.1 Australia's wind energy industry remains small in comparison both with its potential size and with the total size of wind energy installed around the world. However, to date it
Aph Gov
Rating Scale Methodology
1-3: FALSE
Factually incorrect or malicious fabrication.
4-6: PARTIAL
Some truth but context is missing or skewed.
7-9: MOSTLY TRUE
Minor technicalities or phrasing issues.
10: ACCURATE
Perfectly verified and contextually fair.
Methodology: Ratings are determined through cross-referencing official government records, independent fact-checking organizations, and primary source documents.