The Claim
“Denied responsibility after Manus Island detention centre guards let in a mob of locals, resulting in an asylum seeker being shot and dozens more injured. Injuries included slit throats, machete wounds and eyes hanging from sockets.”
Original Sources Provided
✅ FACTUAL VERIFICATION
The core events described in the claim are substantially accurate. On February 16-18, 2014, violent riots and attacks occurred at the Manus Island detention centre in Papua New Guinea, resulting in the death of 23-year-old Iranian asylum seeker Reza Berati and injuries to approximately 60-77 other asylum seekers [1][2].
The official report by former Secretary of the Attorney-General's Department, Robert Cornall, confirmed several key elements of the claim:
- An asylum seeker "was attacked from behind by an unidentified PNG national G4S guard who slashed his neck, causing a 10 to 12 centimetre horizontal slit across his throat" [2]
- Two other asylum seekers were seriously injured - one lost his right eye and another was shot [2]
- A Salvation Army worker (PNG national) was identified as allegedly leading the fatal attack on Reza Berati [2]
- The report confirmed that G4S guards did enter the detention centre and "attacked transferees, causing physical injuries" [2]
The claim that guards "let in" locals is corroborated by multiple sources. The Refugee Action Coalition fact sheet states that "A fence was pushed down from outside, enabling PNG Police and the PNG 'mobile squad' to enter the facility" [3]. An Australian G4S employee also stated that "PNG police stood back and allowed locals to break into the compound" [4].
However, the specific claim about "eyes hanging from sockets" appears to be an exaggeration. While there were serious facial and eye injuries, and one person did lose their right eye entirely [2], the description of "eyes hanging from sockets" is not confirmed in any official reports or mainstream media coverage. This appears to be a sensationalized embellishment.
Missing Context
The claim omits several critical pieces of context:
1. Labor Government Established the Facility
The Manus Island detention centre was reopened in August 2012 by the Gillard Labor government as part of the "Pacific Solution Mark II" [5][6]. The Refugee Action Coalition itself notes: "There is also blood on Labor's hands. The Labor government re-opened Manus Island in November 2012 and Reza Barati was sent there by the Rudd government in August last year" [3]. This was not a Coalition-created facility - they inherited it.
2. Circumstances Leading to the Violence
The Cornall Report found that the riots were triggered by asylum seekers' "anger and frustration" at the former Labor government's permanent resettlement plan, which meant they would never make it to Australia [2]. The protests began when asylum seekers were told they would be resettled in PNG, not Australia. Immigration Minister Scott Morrison stated: "There would have been no incident that night had there been no protests... but the protests in no way could ever justify what happened" [2].
3. Government Did Accept Responsibility for Security Failures
The government accepted all 13 recommendations from the Cornall Report, many relating to security at the centre [2]. While Morrison initially stated he could "guarantee their safety when they remain in the centre," he later acknowledged that attacks did occur inside and security upgrades were needed [2].
4. Predicted Events
Internal G4S documents obtained by the ABC showed the company predicted the events that led to the riots, including the specific dates (17-18 February 2014) on which they were likely to occur [2]. This suggests systemic communication and security failures predated the specific incident.
Source Credibility Assessment
The original sources provided with the claim require scrutiny:
New Matilda (newmatilda.com) - An independent Australian news website founded in 2004 that explicitly positions itself as progressive/left-wing. It has campaigned on refugee rights and has a clear editorial position critical of offshore detention policies [7].
Refugee Action Coalition - An advocacy organization with an explicit political agenda to end offshore detention and "close Manus Island now" [3]. Their fact sheet states: "This is blood on Immigration Minister Scott Morrison and Tony Abbott's hands" [3]. While documenting real events, their framing is overtly political and partisan.
SMH, The Australian, Perth Now - These are mainstream media outlets with generally credible reporting standards.
The claim sources from advocacy organizations (New Matilda, Refugee Action Coalition) that have explicit political positions against offshore detention. While they reported factual events, their framing is designed to maximize political damage to the government of the day.
Labor Comparison
Did Labor do something similar?
Search conducted: "Labor government offshore detention Manus Island Nauru policy history"
Finding: The Manus Island detention centre was reopened by the Gillard Labor government in August 2012 [5][6]. The facility was originally part of John Howard's "Pacific Solution" (2001-2008), closed by Labor in 2008, then reopened by Labor in 2012 due to increased boat arrivals [5].
The Refugee Action Coalition explicitly acknowledges this: "The Labor government re-opened Manus Island in November 2012 and Reza Barati was sent there by the Rudd government in August last year" [3].
Furthermore, the violence was triggered by the Labor government's policy that asylum seekers would never be resettled in Australia - a policy the Coalition continued but did not originate [2].
Comparison: The offshore detention policy and the specific facility involved in this tragedy were established and operated under Labor before the Coalition took office in September 2013. The claim singles out the Coalition for criticism while ignoring Labor's foundational role in creating the circumstances.
Balanced Perspective
The events of February 16-18, 2014, were undoubtedly tragic and represent a serious failure of duty of care. The death of Reza Berati and the injuries to dozens of asylum seekers were the result of violence perpetrated by PNG security personnel, including G4S guards and at least one Salvation Army employee [2].
However, the claim's framing is misleading in several ways:
Selective Attribution: The claim attacks the Coalition for "denying responsibility" while failing to acknowledge that the facility was reopened by Labor in 2012, and the victim was sent there by the Rudd government [3]. Both parties share responsibility for the offshore detention policy.
Exaggerated Descriptions: While serious injuries occurred (including a slashed throat, gunshot wounds, and eye loss), the description of "eyes hanging from sockets" appears to be a sensationalized embellishment not supported by official reports.
Incomplete Timeline: The violence occurred after asylum seekers began protests upon learning they would be resettled in PNG under the policy framework established by the previous Labor government [2].
Government Response: While the initial government response was criticized, all 13 recommendations from the independent Cornall Report were accepted, and significant security upgrades were subsequently implemented [2].
Key context: This is NOT unique to the Coalition. The bipartisan nature of offshore detention policy means both major parties share responsibility for the tragic outcomes at Manus Island. The facility was reopened by Labor, operated under both governments, and has been a source of ongoing controversy regardless of which party held power.
PARTIALLY TRUE
6.0
out of 10
The core facts are substantially accurate: PNG guards and locals did attack asylum seekers, resulting in death and serious injuries including gunshot wounds, a slashed throat, and eye injuries. The claim that the government denied full responsibility has merit, as initial statements downplayed the violence occurring inside the centre.
However, the verdict is "Partially True" rather than "True" because:
- The claim contains sensationalized elements ("eyes hanging from sockets") not supported by evidence
- It fails to acknowledge the facility was reopened by the Labor government in 2012
- It ignores that the victim was sent there by the Rudd government
- It omits that the violence was triggered by policies established under Labor
- It presents the incident as uniquely attributable to Coalition negligence when it reflects systemic failures across both parties' offshore detention policies
The claim is an example of cherry-picking a tragic incident to attack one political party while ignoring the bipartisan nature of the policy that created the circumstances.
Final Score
6.0
OUT OF 10
PARTIALLY TRUE
The core facts are substantially accurate: PNG guards and locals did attack asylum seekers, resulting in death and serious injuries including gunshot wounds, a slashed throat, and eye injuries. The claim that the government denied full responsibility has merit, as initial statements downplayed the violence occurring inside the centre.
However, the verdict is "Partially True" rather than "True" because:
- The claim contains sensationalized elements ("eyes hanging from sockets") not supported by evidence
- It fails to acknowledge the facility was reopened by the Labor government in 2012
- It ignores that the victim was sent there by the Rudd government
- It omits that the violence was triggered by policies established under Labor
- It presents the incident as uniquely attributable to Coalition negligence when it reflects systemic failures across both parties' offshore detention policies
The claim is an example of cherry-picking a tragic incident to attack one political party while ignoring the bipartisan nature of the policy that created the circumstances.
📚 SOURCES & CITATIONS (7)
-
1
abc.net.au
Sarah Ferguson presents Australia's premier daily current affairs program, delivering agenda-setting public affairs journalism and interviews that hold the powerful to account. Plus political analysis from Laura Tingle.
Abc Net -
2
abc.net.au
A Salvation Army worker identified as allegedly leading a fatal attack on Iranian asylum seeker Reza Berati on Manus Island in February is expected to be charged in Papua New Guinea. The PNG national has been named in an official report into the riots which took place at the Manus Island detention centre between February 16 to 18 this year. Mr Berati, 23, died in what the Government describes as a "disturbance" that saw another 60 asylum seekers injured, some seriously.
Abc Net -
3PDF
Manus attacks fact sheet
Refugeeaction Org • PDF Document -
4
news.com.au
News Com
-
5
en.wikipedia.org
Wikipedia -
6
rac-vic.org
Refugee Action Collective (Vic) | Free the refugees! Let them land, let them stay! -
7
abc.net.au
Labor will attack Scott Morrison over the Manus Island riot, but both sides of the political divide are guilty of inhumane policies spanning more than two decades.
Abc Net
Rating Scale Methodology
1-3: FALSE
Factually incorrect or malicious fabrication.
4-6: PARTIAL
Some truth but context is missing or skewed.
7-9: MOSTLY TRUE
Minor technicalities or phrasing issues.
10: ACCURATE
Perfectly verified and contextually fair.
Methodology: Ratings are determined through cross-referencing official government records, independent fact-checking organizations, and primary source documents.